Seattle's Metropolitan Market Cookie: A culinary masterpiece?

Many claim to be the best, but few truly earn the title. The Cookie, from Seattle’s Metropolitan Market, isn’t just a cookie; it's an experience, a testament to the artistry of baking. Its devoted following speaks volumes, a hushed reverence accompanying every mention. I first encountered this legendary treat while in college in Tacoma, spending countless hours exploring the aisles of the Proctor Metropolitan Market. It quickly became a cherished companion.

The Cookie: A Symphony of Flavors and Textures

Served warm and underbaked, straight from the oven, The Cookie is a marvel of culinary engineering. A chocolate lover's dream, it features a squidgy dough enriched with two types of luxurious Callebaut Belgian chocolate – bittersweet and semisweet. The combination creates a symphony of rich, melty chocolate notes. Toasted walnuts provide a satisfying crunch, adding a dimension of earthy, nutty bitterness that beautifully complements the sweetness. A delicate sprinkle of fleur de sel acts as the perfect counterpoint, balancing the overall flavor profile. This is the pinnacle of the chocolate chip cookie, a true apotheosis of Ruth Graves Wakefield’s original Toll House recipe.

A Minor Quibble?

If I were to pinpoint a single flaw, it's the crinkly paper wrapper, which subtly suggests it’s suitable for sharing. I, however, vehemently disagree. This is a cookie meant to be savored in solitary bliss, a personal indulgence too exquisite to share.

Beyond Chocolate: A Peanut Butter Paradise

For those who prefer a different flavor profile, Metropolitan Market has recently introduced a peanut butter version of The Cookie that is equally divine. A peanut butter fiend myself, I can confirm that it’s incredibly rich, packed with intensely satisfying peanut butter flavor. Its texture is uniquely “fudgy,” a delightful contrast to the original chocolate chip cookie’s squidgy texture. This summer, I bought a small cup of their peanut butter cookie bites for a picnic, and let me tell you, it didn't survive the drive. The cookies were simply too tempting to resist! I purchased this cup of cookie bites to share with others and even took them on a trip.

The Verdict: An Essential Seattle Experience

While I initially resisted the claim of being “the” definitive cookie, Metropolitan Market’s signature treat has earned its title. It's a true Seattle staple, a must-try for any visitor, and a constant source of joy for those fortunate enough to live nearby. Beyond its exceptional taste, its warm, underbaked texture offers a comforting experience akin to being enveloped in a warm hug. It has that home-baked taste, without the hassle. If you’re looking for a truly exceptional cookie, look no further. The Cookie is indeed a culinary masterpiece. I will have to visit again soon to indulge in the many treats Metropolitan Market offers. One thing's for sure, The Cookie is a treat you won't soon forget. The Cookie lives up to its hype and is a must-try for anyone visiting Seattle.