The proposed £15bn merger between Vodafone and Three has been dealt a blow after a watchdog said a new rival mobile network may need to be created to ease competition concerns.
In provisional findings published today, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) said it was considering forcing the two companies to give up some assets or spectrum.
Such a move would make existing mobile virtual network operators – such as Sky Mobile and GiffGaff – more competitive or allow a new player to enter the market.
The forced sale of spectrum could threaten to derail the £15bn merger, which would reduce the number of UK mobile network operators from four to three.
Forcing the two companies to give up valuable spectrum threatens to undermine this plan.
However, the CMA said it was “concerned about the practicality of such a remedy”.
In its initial findings regarding the tie-up, the watchdog also warned the deal could lead to tens of millions of customers paying more on their mobile bills. The CMA concluded that the deal would lead to price increases or see customers get a reduced service such as smaller data packages in their contracts.
Competition Concerns and Potential Remedies
The CMA's concerns stem from the potential impact of the merger on competition in the UK mobile market. With the merger reducing the number of major players from four to three, the CMA fears that it could lead to less competitive pressure, resulting in higher prices and reduced service quality for consumers.
Impact on MVNOs and Potential New Entrants
One of the key areas of concern for the CMA is the impact of the merger on Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs). These are smaller operators that lease network capacity from the major players, allowing them to offer services without having to build their own infrastructure. The CMA believes that the merger could make it more difficult for MVNOs to secure favorable wholesale deals, potentially leading to higher prices for their customers.
The CMA is also considering the possibility of creating a new competitor in the market. This could involve the forced sale of assets or spectrum from Vodafone and Three to a new entrant, which could potentially provide a much-needed boost to competition. However, the CMA acknowledges that this solution could be challenging to implement.
Vodafone and Three Respond to CMA Concerns
Vodafone and Three have maintained that the merger is necessary to give them the scale needed to invest in improving their networks and compete effectively with larger rivals. They argue that the deal will ultimately benefit consumers by leading to improved network quality and faster 5G rollouts.
However, the CMA's concerns about the impact on competition and potential price hikes for consumers are significant. The CMA has indicated that it is open to considering remedies that would address these concerns, but it remains to be seen whether Vodafone and Three will be able to offer satisfactory solutions. The final decision on the merger is expected to be made in December.
Key Points
-
The CMA is considering requiring Vodafone and Three to sell assets or spectrum to address these concerns.
-
Vodafone and Three argue that the merger is necessary to give them the scale needed to invest in their networks and compete effectively.
-
The final decision on the merger is expected to be made in December.
The outcome of this investigation will have significant implications for the future of the UK mobile market. If the CMA decides to block the merger or impose stringent remedies, it could have a major impact on Vodafone and Three's plans. The CMA's decision is expected to be a closely watched event in the UK telecommunications industry.
